You win some, you loose some
By Leslie Council

In light of recent protests against President Bush’s proposal to send more troops to the war in Iraq, I began to ask some family members in the military what they thought about it.

I should say, first off, I have never been truly for going to Iraq. I never understood what Saddam Hussein had to do with Osama bin Laden and why we didn’t go after bin Laden, if he was in fact the one, with his organized crew, who schemed against America and took out vital financial and political symbols.

I lost many friends on Sept.11, both at the WTC and at the art school below it. Yet, I have lost more family members a result of their return to Iraq, some on their second tour of it. So I began to ask why. Did they think risking their lives was as result of their duty, a sense of pride that kept them from quitting despite familial pleas or did they really believe in what they were doing?

Three out of the four started with it was their duty, first and foremost to their country, then to their families, who deserve freedom in this country, and thirdly because they knew when they signed up for the reserves that they might be called to war.

So I asked them if it really mattered why they were going to war. One cousin was so bold as to say that he didn’t agree with many aspects of this particular war (this is after returning from both Iraq in 2004 and Desert Storm, earlier), but respected that this president wanted to finish what he started.

He did say in a softer voice with tears swelling in his eyes, that he has a fear of not returning to his two children, ages four and two, and to his wife.

Maybe it was the diversity of their jobs that completely took their views in different directions. My other cousin, quite a bit younger and on her first tour of Iraq, was angry. She was signed up for the reserves unlike the other three signed up for the Army and Marines.

She was angry because, though she initially signed up because, of a vengeful feeling and pride to “protect her country” after Sept.11, she thought this war would be over by now. She didn’t understand how it could have dragged on for so long and in such a skewed direction.

She is so resentful that she has considered going AWOL when she is called up - or even committing suicide. She said that when she signed up, she understood that you “do what you’re told because your life isn’t yours anymore,” but that the war has caused such pain and conflict.

When she left for boot camp, she had a good job in the police force and was a well respected honor roll student attending university, planning to become a lawyer.

When she came back, because she had been gone so long it was hard for her continue her education because she knew she would have to leave again, maybe in the middle of the semester.

She also had to take another job because they had filled her position after a year and half.

I see the war so differently through their eyes after talking with them, but I am angrier that my cousin who did lose his life in this war had to leave his family with little in the way of benefits and a short legacy.

My father’s being a Vietnam veteran always confused me. I didn’t understand why someone would risk his life for another until I worked in the medical field.

Even now I still don’t understand how so many people take for granted the freedom that these soldiers fight for. Many people live their lives as if they shouldn’t be alive, or worse don’t strive to achieve the very goals that these soldiers might have helped their own children with.

America isn’t as free as everyone thinks it is. We’re a capitalist country and wars make money. Weapon manufacturers actually have a vested interest in continuing this war. For those who think more is less, I’m not sorry to say that I believe sending more troops would mean that even fewer come home alive.



Leslie Council may be reached at (915) 831-2500
click to return to newspaper Home Page